Collapse Bro Gets His Stats Wrong
In his recent post, Collapse Bro (Umair Haque, the guy whose every post features “American Collapse”), dropped a statistic that was off by orders of magnitude. He was trying to minimize the problem of mass uncontrolled immigration in Europe:
The problem is hardly just one of demographics — a few thousand refugees are hardly a threat of any sort to societies of millions, who are rich to begin with
Hold it you say: he surely did not say there were only a few thousand refugees entering Europe. Thousands is way too small. He’s much too concerned with accuracy and facts to say that. Surely you are misquoting him. Please read it yourself — it’s about two thirds of the way down in his “Europe is Utopia except for a few teensy weensy problems” apologia.
Why American Collapse is a Warning to the World
Why Social Democracy is an Immune System Against Capitalism Metastasizing into Fascism and Authoritarianism
Of course the stat is wrong. It’s not even close. The “thousands” are actually more than a million. The actual net number of immigrants into Germany in 2015 was estimated at 1.1 million.
His made-up low estimate is a failed attempt to hide a problem that is on display all over Europe: the economically unsustainable contradiction in having generous social benefits and allowing a vast flow of refugees to immigrate and reap those benefits. Governments are soon forced to borrow to provide the additional benefits going to the new arrivals. Eventually this puts a strain on the financial strength of the social safety net and it starts unraveling.
Let’s hope Collapse Bro gets his numbers in the neighborhood of reality next time and have a discussion of the problems threatening to lead to collapse of the EU, or at least more Brexits.